PhD Pathway
By Kathryn Cobleigh
At one point, I thought there was an “acceptable” way to get a PhD: finish your bachelor’s immediately start a master’s and then move to your PhD. Or, if you were really fast-tracked, skip the master’s altogether and go straight into your PhD.
As a young undergraduate, that was incredibly appealing. The idea that I could be an “expert” by my mid-to-late 20s sounded pretty great!
Spoiler alert/TLDR: that’s not how it went. And I’m immensely grateful for that.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with the straight-through academic pathway, and for some it’s the right one. In hindsight, though, it wouldn’t have been the right path for me. Instead, my route to a PhD included several detours, side quests, and periods where I had absolutely no idea what I was doing next.
At the time, many of those periods felt less like valuable career development and more like I was just trying to keep moving. Looking back, they gave me the interpersonal skills, resilience, and, perhaps most importantly, perspective that I brought with me when I eventually started my PhD.
There are three big lessons from that very non-linear journey that have shaped my PhD now.
1. Rejection is part of the game, so keep more than one door open
Straight out of undergrad, I was already searching and applying for PhD programs. I was convinced that the research I had been involved with as an undergraduate was what I wanted to spend my life researching.
To be fair, it was super cool research. But I have since learned something important about myself: I’m very easily “jazzed” about a topic when I am surrounded by people who are passionate about it. That is not necessarily a bad thing, but at the time I wasn’t very good at separating I genuinely want to dedicate years of my life to this from everyone around me is excited and I am feeding off their energy.
After undergrad, I bounced between a few different opportunities for about a year and a half. For the first time, I didn’t have a clear plan, which felt chaotic and incredibly stressful.
During that period, I was also having serious conversations with a potential PhD advisor. It was a new program, it seemed like a great fit, and it would keep me in coral research. Everything sounded like it was essentially a go – until suddenly, it wasn’t.
Funding tightened almost overnight, and what had felt like a shoo-in position became extremely competitive. It felt like the rug had been pulled out from under me.
Thankfully, I had also applied to a master’s program as my “back-up.”
That back-up became the first domino leading to the PhD I am doing now.
It wasn’t necessarily the program I had foreseen for myself, but it opened my eyes to how many different directions I could take within coral reef and environmental research. More importantly, the program suited the way I learn far better that I could have anticipated. It was hands-on, field-based, and heavy on experiential learning.
I learned plenty of science, but I also learned how to think on my feet, adapt when plan inevitably changed, and become more comfortable figuring things out as I go. Those are difficult skills to teach in a classroom, and in my line of work, incredibly valuable ones.
Throughout my master’s and in the years that followed I probably contacted or had serious conversations with eight to ten universities over several years.
All but one ultimately resulted in either a flat-out rejection or an opportunity that faded away for one reason or another.
At first, those rejections stung. Like, seriously stung.
Eventually, though, rejections became more of a number that a genuine heartbreak. And with enough distance, I can see that some of the opportunities I was most devastated to lose would have required sacrifices I said I was willing to make but realistically wasn’t.
You can hear “no” a lot. At the end of the day, you only really need one “yes;” as long as it’s the yes you actually want.

2. Experience outside academia still counts
I am a big proponent of taking time between academic programs if you can swing it. That might mean traveling, working, trying something adjacent to your field, or doing something completely unrelated.
For me, it mostly meant work.
Initially, I bounced between technician positions in different coral research labs. They were academic-adjacent enough to feel comfortable while still giving me experiences I hadn’t had as a student.
During this time, environmental jobs became scarce and I ended up stepping away from marine science entirely and into what I affectionally refer to as my “chicken grease job,” which is a whole different story!
That was an interesting period of my career.
On the one hand, I was having a minor identity crisis because, for the first time, I wasn’t working in marine science. On the other hand, I was making decent money for the first time and working an actually 9-to-5 job where I could go home and have a life completely unrelated to my job.
At the time, stepping away from marine science felt like stepping off the path. Looking back, I don’t see it that way at all.
Working outside of academia gave me perspective on what I valued about science, what I missed when I wasn’t doing it, and what I didn’t want to sacrifice just for the sake of saying I was progressing academically. It also reinforced that skills don’t suddenly stop being valuable because you learned them somewhere other than a university.

3. Figure out your non-negotiables
Every university I applied to, every supervisor I spoke with, every job I took, and every rejection made me a little more specific about what I actually wanted from a PhD.
By the time I was applying to the University of Technology Sydney, I had a much clearer idea of what I needed form a program and a supervisor, and what I wanted to bring to that relationship in return.
I had learned some red flags, some green flags, and what kind of supervisions allowed me to do my best work.
I wanted a supervisor I could get along with personally and professionally. I wanted someone present and supportive who would push me but also give me autonomy. I wanted to have genuine say in the direction of my research rather than inherit a project. And I wanted to live somewhere I could build a life, have hobbies, and be a person outside of my PhD.
Those things might have seem secondary to me when I first started looking at PhD programs. Initially, the project was everything. If the research sounds exciting enough, I thought the res -- the supervision style, whether I got along with my advisor, where I could be living, and whether I could build a life -- were details I could figure out later.
By the time I was looking at UTS, that order had almost complete flipped.
I had realized that a PhD is several years of your life, not just a research project. Having supervisors I genuinely liked and trusted, feeling supported while still having independence, and being somewhere I could have friends, hobbies, and an identity outside of my research were no longer nice extras. They were some of the most important criteria in deciding whether a program was right for me.

Of course, I still wanted to be excited about the science. But I had also learned that I can get excited about a lot of different questions when I am surrounded by passionate people and given the room to explore them. Finding a program a program, where I could help shape the direction of my own project was the bonus. Finding the people and environment where I felt I could actually enjoy the process of doing a PhD was the priority.
Bringing it all together:
Now that I am at UTS, one of the things I appreciate most is looking around and seeing just how many different paths brought people here. I sit alongside PhD students who came straight form undergrad, “older” students like me who took a few detours along the way, people balancing research with raising kids, and others who had entirely different careers before deciding to come back to pursue a PhD.
So much of our lives, we are given this idea that these is a timeline we are supposed to follow; that by a certain age we should have reached certain milestones, established a career, or figured out what we want to do. Academia certainly has its own pressures, but one of the things I have come to love about doing a PhD is that in many ways those timelines go out the window.
There isn’t a right age to start a PhD, and there isn’t one pathway that better prepares you for it. What matters far more is what you bring with you when you get here: the skills you have picked up along the way, the perspective your experiences have given you, your willingness to learn, and your attitude when things don’t go to plan.
I used to think taking longer to get here meant I was somehow behind. Now, sitting among people who arrive through completely different routes, I don’t think there is such a thing.
It doesn’t really matter when you decide to take on the adventure. What matters if that you arrive ready to contribute, ready to learn, and still excited to create some new (and exciting!) knowledge along the way.


Here’s to circuitous pathways!
You’re a star, however you get there!
Miss you!
B.
What a brilliant read! There is no correct path - Thanks Kathryn!